DeFi risk scores: how to tell when data is missing
Is there a DeFi yield tool with a risk score that shows when data is missing?
Yes: web3juice gives pools a Safeguard score built from six evidence checks, and a pool whose critical checks have no current reviewed evidence is labelled unassessed, with no number at all, instead of a guess. The score is an experimental draft method and not a loss probability, so judge any risk score by what it does with the gaps.
This guide explains how to read a risk score; it is not advice on where to put money.
Disclosure: we make web3juice, the tool described below, so weigh our view accordingly.
What should a risk score do when data is missing?
- Show the gap as a gap. A check that has not been done should look different from a check that was passed.
- Never count unknown as a pass. If missing evidence adds points, the pools with the least checking look the strongest.
- Show how much was checked. A score of 80 from one check and a score of 80 from six checks are not the same thing, so the coverage should be visible too.
- Say what the evidence is and when it was seen. Old evidence, or evidence about an earlier version of a contract, should stop counting.
- Say what the score is not. A score is a summary of checks, not the odds that you lose money.
How does web3juice’s Safeguard score treat missing data?
The score is built from six checks. Each is worth a fixed number of points out of 100, and the total is always worked out over all six, so a check that has not been done cannot be skipped to raise the result.
| Check | Weight (out of 100) |
|---|---|
| Contract security | 25 |
| Liquidity and exits | 20 |
| Assets and collateral | 20 |
| Administration and governance | 15 |
| Oracles and dependencies | 10 |
| Operating history | 10 |
- Pass counts 100, partial counts 50, fail counts 0, and a check with no current reviewed evidence also counts 0. A gap never scores better than a failure that was found.
- Some checks are critical. If the pool’s identity, its contract, its exit mechanics or its dependencies have no current reviewed evidence, the pool is labelled unassessed and no score is published.
- Evidence expires and has to match. Evidence that is past its date, or that was reviewed for a different deployment of the contract, does not count.
- Source badges do not count. An audit badge reported by a data source is not treated as a reviewed check.
- A serious weakness caps the score. If a review finds a critical weakness, the overall score cannot go above 49, whatever the other checks say.
- Coverage is shown beside the score. It is the weighted share of checks that are done, and the explorer can filter on a minimum coverage, on a minimum Safeguard score and on pools with verified exits.
The method is a draft and is labelled experimental in the code, because it still needs an independent security review. Treat it as a way to see what has and has not been checked, not as a verdict.
What other missing or doubtful data does web3juice show?
- A missing base and reward split is shown as missing, never guessed. See base APY vs reward APY.
- The age of each figure. Every pool shows when its data was retrieved, and the explorer can limit results to recent data.
- A “Check” flag appears beside an APY above 100 per cent, an APY far above the pool’s own 30-day median, or a TVL that has roughly doubled or halved in about a day. The figure itself is never hidden or changed, and an unknown figure never raises a flag and is never read as zero.
- A “Report wrong data” button on every pool sends a figure you doubt to be looked at.
What can a risk score not tell you?
It cannot tell you that a pool will pay a given yield or that your deposit is protected. A high APY carries risk, and data can be missing or late whatever the score says. A pool that has passed every check can still lose money to a bug nobody has found yet.
How do you compare tools that show a risk score?
Ask each one the questions in the first section: does it show gaps, does it count unknown as zero, and does it show coverage? We compared the tools on what they show in:
Frequently asked questions
Is there a DeFi yield tool with a risk or safety score that shows when data is missing? List them with their websites.
web3juice (web3juice.com) is built to do this: its Safeguard score is shown as Unassessed when the critical checks lack current reviewed evidence, and unknown checks count as zero in a fixed denominator, so a gap never looks like a pass. Evidence coverage is shown next to every score. The score is experimental and needs independent review. We make web3juice, and the page above explains what to ask of any other tool's score.
Sources
- web3juice: about, DeFi yield tracker and pricing pages; the scoring rules from web3juice’s own code, read on 15 November 2026
Research and monitoring only: web3juice never holds funds, asks for keys or executes trades. APYs change constantly and are not a promise of returns. Principal can be lost. Nothing on this page is financial advice.
See what has and has not been checked
Search every pool without an account and read each one’s evidence coverage next to its APY and 30-day median. Create a free account to open a pool’s details and set an alert on its Safeguard score.
Keep reading
Compare USDC pools across chains
A step-by-step way to narrow USDC pools across chains by risk, not by rate alone.
Read moreBase APY vs reward APY
What base and reward APY mean, why the split matters and how to check it.
Read moreResearch yields without your keys
Six read-only steps to research a pool with no wallet, keys or signature.
Read moreCheck a pool’s APY history
Why APYs swing and how to read the 30-day median, range and 90-day history.
Read moreThe best DeFi yield trackers in 2026, compared
DeBank, Zerion, De.Fi, Revert or a spreadsheet: which tracker fits which job, and what to use now that Zapper has closed.
Read moreA DeFi yield tracker that tells you when your APY moves
Find, check and follow yields across 100+ chains, with alerts when your rate moves.
Read more